Memorandum submitted by The Waterways
Trust (BW 39)
1. ROLE AND
REMIT
The Waterways Trust is an independent charity
established at the instigation of British Waterways (BW) in 1999.
The role and remit of the Trust was endorsed by Government in
the white paper, Waterways for Tomorrow 2000 (WfT).
WfT recognised that delivery of the Government's
objectives for the waterways would be assisted by a national waterway
charity with:
the freedoms of working outside the
public sector, where necessary working as an enablera vehicle
for finance and funding, holding assets and benefiting from favourable
tax status (eg, Gift Aid);
access to charitable funding for
waterway projects; and
capacity to champion waterways and
to involve the wider community in waterway-based activity and
fundraising.
The Trust has a UK-wide remit to help realise
the educational, social, economic and environmental benefits of
waterways for all sections of the community.
Our vision is to see Britain's waterways supported,
valued and enjoyed by all sections of the community.
2. ACTIVITIES
The Waterways Trust works with others in three
main areas:
2.1 Fundraising
The Trust raises up to £2 million per annum
for waterway-based projects that enable people and communities
to enjoy, and gain benefit from, their waterways. The main themes
of the projects for which we raise funds are:
Education and learning.
Environment and conservation.
Activity, health and recreation.
Access, arts and community involvement.
2.2 Regeneration
Since 1999 The Waterways Trust, in partnership
with BW, has enabled over £40 million of new investment in
Britain's waterways using the freedoms we have outside the public
sector. We also work to bring together the complex partnerships
that underpin waterway regeneration projects.
2.3 The National Waterways Museum and Archive
The Trust operates the National Waterways Museum
and Archive based at three centres: Ellesmere Port, Gloucester
Docks and Stoke Bruerne, Northamptonshire. They currently attract
about 60,000 visitors a year, including over 10,000 education
and learning visits.
The inland waterways collection, held by the National
Waterways Museum, is Government-owned, vested with BW, under the
1968 Transport Act but managed on long-term loan by The Waterways
Trust. The collection is Designated as nationally important by
Government.
3. FUNDING
The Trust's activities are currently supported
by a funding contract with BW worth £920,000 per annum. Of
this, £465,000 supports the operating costs of the Museums
and Archives, £235,000 supports the fundraising activity,
and the balance of £220,000 contributes to central costs.
The Trust has a turnover of £4.6 million per annum.
4. COMMENTS TO
THE ENQUIRY
The transformation of the waterways network
over the last nine years has been a remarkable story and an undoubted
policy success for Government. The Trust is pleased to have contributed
to this success, working as a partner with BW on major regeneration
projects, fundraising and the National Waterways Museum.
The Trust is concerned, therefore, that the
funding changes for BW indicate an apparent retreat by Government
from investment in the long-term maintenance of inland waterways.
This will lead to a reduction in maintenance investment, increasing
the risk of more serious structural failures and a vicious circle
of declining confidence amongst investors and stakeholders. This
must not be allowed to happen.
The focus of our comments to the Committee is
the potential implications of the changes in the DEFRA funding
for BW on the work of the Trust.
As noted above, the Trust receives substantial
funding from BW to support its work.
In the long-term, the Trust intends to reduce
its dependency on BW. We have made moves towards this end in recent
years, but the Trust is likely to remain dependent on BW for its
core revenue funding for the foreseeable future.
The changes in grant for BW announced by DEFRA
may reduce the ability of BW to continue funding The Waterways
Trust at current levels with major consequences for our work,
particularly:
Fundraising programmes.
National Waterways Museum.
4.1 Fundraising
In the six years to 31 March 2006, the Trust
raised £11.8 million to support waterway projects, general
funds and investment in the National Waterways Museum. As part
of this, we received cash donations from over 14,000 individuals
in response to our appeals.
As a result of our work, many new people have
been made aware of their local waterway, 600,000 have visited
the National Waterways Museum and many thousands have been involved
directly, taking active part in waterway projects, benefiting
their community, their health, learning and general well-being.
The work we undertake is designed to complement
the work of BW and other public sector waterway owners and operators
and is not replicated by other organisations.
The fundraising work of the Trust is now established
but needs continuing support to sustain it and develop further.
An unintended consequence of the changes in funding to BW could
be to put these programmes at risk should BW be unable to sustain
their financial support.
4.2 The National Waterways Museum
Government policy on free museum entry has been
a resounding success. A report produced by the London School of
Economics in December 2006 noted that more people are visiting
museums than attending Premiership football matches and free-to-enter
museums are contributing £1.5 billion to the economy. According
to the DCMS, there has been an 83% increase in total visits to
formerly charging museums since admission charges were scrapped.
However, this policy has created an expectation
in the mind of the public that all museums are free to enter.
The National Waterways Museum has faced enormous pressures since
free entry for nationally-funded museums was introduced. The Museum
receives no Government funding and must charge for entry. Visitors
to the Museum have declined sharply since the free entry policy
was introduced in 2001.
The current funding of the Museum is unsustainable.
The liabilities of managing the museums and managing the publicly-owned
collections, outstrip their income earning potential. This is
despite improved customer service and commercial performance,
investment of nearly £5 million in improved galleries and
interpretation, and several rounds of cost-cutting, efficiency
savings and rigorous review.
We have approached Government, both DCMS and
Museums Libraries and Archives Council (MLA), for assistance.
An Independent Strategic Review, jointly commissioned with MLA
in 2006, estimated that £1 million per annum is needed to
put the Museum on a secure footing, and to deliver a new vision
for a Museums without Walls reaching out on the waterway network.
However, the first priority is for £450,000 per annum to
enable us to offer free entry. This would double visitor numbers
in two years and enable the Museum to grow and develop new revenue
streams that would help stabilise the Museum finances.
DCMS recognises the strength of our case but
to date has not provided new funding.
There is precedent for Government to intervene.
In other cases, Government has acted to safeguard collections
which face similar pressures. Notable examples are, the National
Coal Mining Museum for England and the Peoples History Museum,
both of which now enjoy Government funding, offer free entry and
have seen their visitor numbers increase two-fold.
Faced with current and continuing pressures
on their funding, which have resulted in 180 job losses, BW is
unable to offer the new funding now urgently needed. Unless DCMS
comes forward with assistance in the near future, the National
Waterways Museum is at risk.
A background note on the National Waterways
Museum is provided in Annex 1.
5. CONCLUSION
5.1 The changes in grant available to BW
may reduce BW's ability to sustain its funding to the Trust. This
would damage the Trust's fundraising programme and the benefits
we can deliver in terms of:
Education and learning.
Environment and conservation.
Activity, health and recreation.
Access, arts and community involvement.
5.2 The costs of operating the National
Waterways Museum and managing the publicly-owned collection and
archive, outstrip their income earning potential. New revenue
funding is urgently needed.
The first priority is for £450,000 per
annum to enable us to offer free entry. This would double visitor
numbers in two years providing access to many who are unable to
pay and help stabilise the Museum finances.
The changes in grant available to BW mean that
BW clearly cannot provide increased support and may have to cut
future funding. This sharpens still further the need for the museums
to be provided with new revenue funding from DCMS.
|