Conclusions and Recommendations
1. The NHS could save more than £200
million a year, without affecting patient care, by GPs prescribing
lower cost but equally effective medicines.
Many drugs are available in both branded and generic versions,
and the latter is usually much cheaper than the brand name drug,
for which the manufacturers have to recover research and development
costs.
2. The proportion of prescriptions written
by chemical name rather than by brand name, known as generic prescribing,
rose from 51% in April 1994 to 83% in September 2006.
But only 59% of prescription items were actually dispensed as
generics in 2005, mainly because not all drugs prescribed were
available in generic form. For some common conditions doctors
have a choice of clinically equally effective drugs, some of which
are available in generic form whilst others are only available
as branded medicines. Where it is clinically appropriate, GPs
should prescribe those available in generic form.
3. The proportion of lower cost prescriptions
for some common conditions varies greatly between Primary Care
Trusts (PCTs), for example between 28% and 86% for statins.
Strategic Health Authorities should work with the National Prescribing
Centre to spread best practice in prescribing and help those PCTs
that have difficulty implementing switching programmes to learn
from PCTs that have successfully done so.
4. Comparing GP practices and PCTs on indicators
of efficient prescribing is an effective way of influencing prescribing
behaviour. The Department, in conjunction
with the NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement, should
develop more 'Better Care, Better Value' prescribing indicators
to measure the proportion of generics dispensed and the level
of potential savings where more cost effective prescribing would
generate significant savings, such as for renin-angiotensins used
to treat high blood pressure. Strategic Health Authorities should
use these indicators to hold PCTs to account for prescribing costs.
5. Despite large variations between PCTs in
prescribing efficiency, nearly all GP practices achieve maximum
points on the 'medicines management' indicators in the Quality
and Outcomes Framework. Practices are
rewarded for meeting a prescribing adviser 'at least annually',
and agreeing 'up to three' actions relating to prescribing. The
Department should strengthen the medicines management indicators
when the Quality and Outcomes Framework is next renegotiated,
and set more ambitious prescribing improvement targets for practices
in order to be awarded the medicine management points. The Framework
should also reward GPs for prescribing drugs that are available
in generic form when clinically appropriate.
6. One in five GPs responding to the NAO's
survey said pharmaceutical companies had more influence on prescribing
decisions than official advisers. Whenever
a gift is given by a company there is a risk that it will have
an inappropriate influence on the recipient's behaviour. The Department
should specify the minimal level above which gifts, hospitality,
etc provided to prescribers by pharmaceutical companies should
be disclosed to the PCT. PCTs should publish an annual register
of this information.
7. Hospital consultants' prescribing choices
are bound by agreed 'formularies' of cost effective drugs, but
GPs are generally not subject to formularies.
Although prescribing decisions must be sensitive to the needs
of the individual patient, evidence on the cost and clinical effectiveness
of treatments for a particular disease should apply consistently
across the country. The Department should encourage PCTs to pilot
joint primary/secondary care formularies. Strategic Health Authorities
should work with the National Prescribing Centre to promote agreement
and consistency of formularies across primary and secondary care,
and across PCTs.
8. 88% of prescription items are dispensed
free, and the remainder for a standard charge not directly linked
to actual cost. The Department should
do more to make patients aware of the costs of drugs, and hence
the importance of not wasting them, for example by displaying
on dispensed drugs information such as the cost of the specific
items dispensed or an indication of the typical cost of items
to the NHS.
9. Unused and wasted drugs cost the NHS at
least £100 million a year. The Department
of Health does not have robust or up to date information on the
cost of drugs wastage or a good understanding of the varied and
complex reasons why patients do not always use their drugs. It
should commission research to establish the extent to which medicines
are not used, and establish the reasons why patients do not take
their drugs.
10. Generic versions of drugs can vary considerably
in appearance, colour and packaging. This
variation can be confusing for patients, particularly elderly
patients on several medications, and can increase the risk of
patients taking their drugs wrongly, or not at all. The Department
should explore with the industry the scope to achieve greater
consistency of appearance, labelling and/or packaging of the more
common drugs supplied to the NHS.
|