Conclusions
and recommendations
1. In spring 2007 there were three million
workless households in the United Kingdom, representing 16% of
all working age households.
The Government's aim to achieve 80% employment will require the
Department to help some 1.6 million economically inactive people
into work, and many of these people are likely to be from workless
households, where no one in the household over the age of 16 is
in employment.
2. Job entry rates from existing New Deal
programmes are levelling off or declining, reflecting the need
to tackle worklessness amongst some of the hardest groups of benefit
claimants to assist. The Department should
use its evaluation of the direct and indirect costs and benefits
of New Deal programmes to identify ways to improve programme effectiveness.
Programmes need to be more flexible so that clients who face multiple
barriers to work can access packages of assistance according to
need, without being restricted on the basis of programme.
3. The cost of getting people into work through
the Department's employment programmes is higher than the subsequent
savings generated over one year for all but two of the programmes.
Unquantifiable social benefits may also accrue from higher employment
rates, but the Department needs to increase the cost effectiveness
of programmes, targeting those programmes which make the lowest
contribution. It should use its data on successful cases to help
identify how to increase the numbers finding a job, and should
also reduce programme costs and/or increase effectiveness, by
using telephone reminders to reduce the number of work-focused
interviews lost through people not turning up.
4. Only around 200 people join the New Deal
for Partners programme each month, and few enter work directly
as a result. Evaluations suggest that
in 2005-06 only 61 of the jobs gained by programme participants
were additional to those that would have been gained without the
programme. Programmes aimed at benefit claimants' partners can
contribute to tackling child poverty. The Department should establish
why claimants' partners reject support and revise the programme
content and its marketing accordingly.
5. Outreach services for workless people do
not reflect the fact that 60% of workless households are concentrated
in 40 districts across the United Kingdom.
Organisations with a good understanding of local communities'
needs are best placed to reach out to such households. Jobcentre
Plus districts should work with relevant local partners to develop
outreach strategies which reflect local priorities and goals,
and to encourage data sharing so that potential clients can be
readily identified and targeted with appropriate help.
6. Work-focused interviews are used to assist
workless people who receive benefits, but they have not been used
to assist workless people who are not required to attend an interview
as a condition of receiving benefit. Jobcentre
Plus has progressively increased the frequency of work-focused
interviews and the groups required to attend them, and plans to
use more frequent reminders to boost attendance by workless partners
of benefit claimants. It should widen the use of work-focused
interviews to people who do not receive income support to raise
awareness of the services and support available and activating
people to look for work.
7. Recipients of incapacity benefit receive
statutory sick pay for six months before being offered any support
in returning to work. Early intervention
is crucial in helping people to avoid long spells of worklessness,
and is particularly important for those facing multiple barriers
in addition to disability. The Department for Work and Pensions
and Jobcentre Plus should offer earlier support to people on statutory
sick pay who are likely to claim incapacity benefit.
8. It is too early to assess the impact of
the Department for Innovation, Universities and Skill's decision
to prioritise the funding of basic skills and employability skills
courses. The early signs are positive,
such as the increase in the number of learners on priority courses
in 2005-06. The Department and the Learning and Skills Council
should market these courses so as to ensure that workless people
are fully aware of the impact that the qualifications will have
on their employability.
9. The Department could not tell us how many
of the 2.9 million people who had started a New Deal programme
were still participating in it; nor what proportion of workless
households chose not to work rather than being out of work due
to personal circumstances. The Department
needs such information to inform its forward strategy, including
better estimates of the numbers in the hardest to reach groups
and success rates in promoting employment amongst the workless.
|